Jimmy’s Place is a gem. Old school pizza place that’s been holding it down in Forest Park for 15 years, but the vibe makes it feel like it’s been around for 50. Housed in an old building on the Madison strip, Jimmy’s has a nice airy dining room with a good bar feel to it. It’s clearly beloved by the locals.

The pizza at Jimmy’s Place is great. Thin crust pies with solid everything and great balance. Little cornmeal on the crust, just greasy enough, and quality toppings.

Bringing quality and atmosphere together at Jimmy’s, they’ve got a great thing going on out there. Definitely get out to Jimmy’s Place when you can.

6/22/17

# of people in attendance: 5

# pizzas sampled: 3

pizzas: pepp + onion, ½ sausage + mushroom ½ sausage, something else

SCORES

atmosphere: 7.3

sauce: 5.6

cheese: 7.2

toppings: 6.5

crust: 8

price: 6.6

overall score: 6.9